← MathScape

Error Estimation with Differentials

MATH161
Reference: Stewart 2.9  •  Chapter: 2  •  Section: 9

Navigation: Wiki Home > Skills > Error Estimation with Differentials

Error Estimation with Differentials

Measurement Uncertainty is Inevitable

Every physical measurement has uncertainty. A ruler might measure a length as $10.3 \pm 0.1$ cm. A scale might give a mass as $2.50 \pm 0.02$ kg. These uncertainties propagate through calculations.

Here's the problem: if you measure the radius of a sphere with some error, and then compute the volume, how much error is in the volume? The radius error "amplifies" through the formula $V = \frac{4}{3}\pi r^3$.

Differentials provide an elegant way to estimate this error propagation without tedious exact calculations.

Prerequisite Map

This skill
Error Estimation with Differentials
Unlocks
Related RatesMultivariable Error Propagation

Quick Reference

Property Value
Concept Linear Approximations and Differentials
Chapter 2.9
Difficulty Intermediate
Time ~20 minutes

Key Concepts

The Error Propagation Principle

If $y = f(x)$ and we measure $x$ with an error $\Delta x$, then the resulting error in $y$ is approximately:

$$\boxed{\Delta y \approx dy = f'(x) \cdot dx}$$

Here $dx = \Delta x$ represents the measurement error in $x$.

Types of Error

Error Type Definition Formula
Absolute error The actual amount of error $\Delta y \approx dy = f'(x)\,dx$
Relative error Error as a fraction of the value $\frac{\Delta y}{y} \approx \frac{dy}{y}$
Percentage error Relative error × 100% $\frac{\Delta y}{y} \times 100\%$

Why Relative Error Matters

An error of 1 cm is:

Relative error tells you how significant the error is compared to what you're measuring.

The Error Amplification Factor

For $y = f(x)$, the relative error relationship is:

$$\frac{dy}{y} = \frac{f'(x)}{f(x)} \cdot dx$$

The factor $\frac{f'(x)}{f(x)}$ determines how much the relative error gets amplified.

Common Formulas and Their Error Behavior

Formula $dy$ Relative Error $\frac{dy}{y}$
$y = x^n$ $nx^{n-1}dx$ $n\frac{dx}{x}$
$y = kx$ $k\,dx$ $\frac{dx}{x}$
$y = \sqrt{x}$ $\frac{dx}{2\sqrt{x}}$ $\frac{1}{2}\frac{dx}{x}$
$y = \frac{1}{x}$ $-\frac{dx}{x^2}$ $-\frac{dx}{x}$

Key pattern: For $y = x^n$, the relative error in $y$ is $n$ times the relative error in $x$.

Practice Problems

Level 1 Finding Maximum Error

The side of a square is measured as $s = 12$ cm with a possible error of $\pm 0.3$ cm. Use differentials to estimate the maximum error in the calculated area.

Thought Process

The area is $A = s^2$.

The maximum error in $A$ is approximately $dA = \frac{dA}{ds} \cdot ds = 2s \cdot ds$.

Substitute $s = 12$ and $ds = 0.3$ (use the magnitude for maximum error).

Show Answer

$A = s^2$

$dA = 2s \cdot ds = 2(12)(0.3) = 7.2$ cm²

The maximum error in the area is approximately 7.2 cm².

Level 2 Relative and Percentage Error

For the square in Level 1 (side $s = 12$ cm, error $\pm 0.3$ cm):

(a) Find the relative error in the area.

(b) Find the percentage error in the area.

(c) How does this compare to the percentage error in the side measurement?

Thought Process

Relative error = $\frac{dA}{A}$

We found $dA = 7.2$ cm². We need $A = s^2 = 144$ cm².

For (c), compare percentage error in area to percentage error in side ($\frac{ds}{s}$).

Show Answer

(a) $A = 12^2 = 144$ cm²

Relative error: $\frac{dA}{A} = \frac{7.2}{144} = 0.05$

(b) Percentage error: $0.05 \times 100\% = 5\%$

(c) Percentage error in side: $\frac{0.3}{12} \times 100\% = 2.5\%$

The percentage error in the area (5%) is twice the percentage error in the side (2.5%).

This makes sense! Since $A = s^2$, the relative error formula gives: $$\frac{dA}{A} = 2\frac{ds}{s}$$

Level 3 Volume of a Sphere

The radius of a sphere is measured as $r = 15$ cm with a maximum error of $0.1$ cm.

(a) Estimate the maximum error in the calculated volume.

(b) Find the relative error in the volume.

(c) If the measurement error in $r$ is 0.67%, what is the percentage error in $V$?

Thought Process

$V = \frac{4}{3}\pi r^3$

$dV = 4\pi r^2 \, dr$ (derivative of $V$ times $dr$)

For the relative error, use the pattern: for $V = kr^3$, the relative error is $3 \times$ the relative error in $r$.

Show Answer

(a) Maximum error in volume:

$V = \frac{4}{3}\pi r^3$

$\frac{dV}{dr} = 4\pi r^2$

$dV = 4\pi r^2 \, dr = 4\pi (15)^2 (0.1) = 4\pi (225)(0.1) = 90\pi \approx 283$ cm³

(b) Relative error:

$V = \frac{4}{3}\pi (15)^3 = \frac{4}{3}\pi (3375) = 4500\pi$ cm³

$\frac{dV}{V} = \frac{90\pi}{4500\pi} = \frac{90}{4500} = 0.02 = 2\%$

(c) Direct approach using the rule:

For $V = kr^3$, relative error in $V$ = $3 \times$ relative error in $r$.

If $\frac{dr}{r} = 0.67\%$, then $\frac{dV}{V} = 3(0.67\%) = 2\%$. ✓

Level 4 Period of a Pendulum

The period of a simple pendulum is $T = 2\pi\sqrt{\frac{L}{g}}$, where $L$ is the length and $g$ is the acceleration due to gravity (constant).

A pendulum has length $L = 1.00$ m measured with an error of $\pm 0.5$ cm.

(a) Find an expression for $dT$ in terms of $T$, $L$, and $dL$.

(b) What is the percentage error in $T$ if the percentage error in $L$ is 0.5%?

(c) Is the period more or less sensitive to length errors than the volume of a sphere is to radius errors?

Thought Process

Write $T = 2\pi\sqrt{L/g} = (2\pi/\sqrt{g}) \cdot L^{1/2}$.

So $T$ is proportional to $L^{1/2}$.

For $y = x^n$, relative error in $y$ is $n$ times relative error in $x$.

Here $n = 1/2$, so relative error in $T$ is $(1/2)$ times relative error in $L$.

Show Answer

(a) Rewriting: $T = 2\pi\sqrt{\frac{L}{g}} = \frac{2\pi}{\sqrt{g}} \cdot L^{1/2}$

$\frac{dT}{dL} = \frac{2\pi}{\sqrt{g}} \cdot \frac{1}{2}L^{-1/2} = \frac{\pi}{\sqrt{gL}}$

More elegantly: $$\frac{dT}{T} = \frac{1}{2}\frac{dL}{L}$$

So: $dT = \frac{T}{2L} \cdot dL$

(b) If percentage error in $L$ is 0.5%, then: $$\text{Percentage error in } T = \frac{1}{2}(0.5\%) = 0.25\%$$

(c) Comparing:

  • Period ($T \propto L^{1/2}$): Error multiplied by $\frac{1}{2}$
  • Volume ($V \propto r^3$): Error multiplied by $3$

The period is much less sensitive to length errors than volume is to radius errors.

The square root "dampens" errors, while the cube "amplifies" them.

Level 5 Designing for Error Tolerance

A cylindrical tank has radius $r$ and height $h$. The volume is $V = \pi r^2 h$.

Currently, $r = 3$ m and $h = 10$ m, and both measurements have the same absolute error of $\pm 0.05$ m.

(a) Find the maximum error in $V$ by computing $dV$ with both $dr$ and $dh$ contributing. Use: $$dV = \frac{\partial V}{\partial r}dr + \frac{\partial V}{\partial h}dh = 2\pi rh\,dr + \pi r^2\,dh$$

(b) Which measurement (radius or height) contributes more to the volume error?

(c) If you could reduce the error in only one measurement, which would have a bigger impact on reducing volume error?

(d) Explain your answer to (c) in terms of the relative importance of $r$ and $h$ in the volume formula.

Thought Process

This is a multivariable problem, but we can handle it by adding the contributions.

For maximum error, assume both errors are in the worst direction (both positive or both negative).

Compare the two terms $2\pi rh\,dr$ and $\pi r^2\,dh$ with the given values.

The radius appears squared in $V = \pi r^2 h$, so errors in $r$ get amplified more.

Show Answer

(a) Maximum error calculation:

$dV = 2\pi rh\,dr + \pi r^2\,dh$

With $r = 3$, $h = 10$, $dr = dh = 0.05$:

Error from $dr$: $2\pi(3)(10)(0.05) = 3\pi \approx 9.42$ m³

Error from $dh$: $\pi(3)^2(0.05) = 0.45\pi \approx 1.41$ m³

Maximum total error: $dV = 3.45\pi \approx 10.84$ m³

(b) Comparison:

  • Error from radius: $3\pi \approx 9.42$ m³
  • Error from height: $0.45\pi \approx 1.41$ m³

The radius measurement contributes about 6.7 times more to the volume error!

(c) Reducing error in the radius would have a much bigger impact on reducing volume error, since the radius term dominates.

(d) Explanation:

In $V = \pi r^2 h$, the radius is squared. This means:

  • A 1% error in $r$ causes a 2% error in $V$ (from the $r^2$ term)
  • A 1% error in $h$ causes only a 1% error in $V$ (linear term)

Even though both measurements have the same absolute error, the radius error is "amplified" by the squared relationship. This is why precision in $r$ matters more than precision in $h$.

General principle: When a quantity appears with a higher power, its measurement error has a proportionally larger effect.

CCI-Style Conceptual Questions

Level 3 Conceptual: When Does Error Shrink?

For which formula would a 2% error in the input $x$ result in less than 2% error in the output $y$?

(A) $y = x^2$

(B) $y = x^3$

(C) $y = \sqrt{x}$

(D) $y = 5x$

Thought Process

For $y = x^n$, the relative error in $y$ is $n$ times the relative error in $x$.

We want the output error to be less than the input error, so we need $n < 1$.

Check each option for the power of $x$.

Show Answer

For $y = x^n$, relative error in $y$ = $\vert n\vert \times$ relative error in $x$.

  • (A) $y = x^2$: Error multiplied by 2 → 4% error (worse)
  • (B) $y = x^3$: Error multiplied by 3 → 6% error (worse)
  • (C) $y = \sqrt{x} = x^{1/2}$: Error multiplied by $\frac{1}{2}$ → 1% error (better!)
  • (D) $y = 5x$: Error multiplied by 1 → 2% error (same)

Answer: (C)

The square root dampens errors because $n = \frac{1}{2} < 1$.

Level 4 Conceptual: Error Behavior Near Critical Points

Consider $y = x^2 - 4x + 5$.

At which value of $x$ would a small measurement error in $x$ cause the smallest error in $y$?

(A) $x = 0$

(B) $x = 2$

(C) $x = 3$

(D) $x = 5$

Thought Process

The error in $y$ is $dy = f'(x) \cdot dx$.

For a fixed $dx$, the error $\vert dy\vert $ is smallest when $\vert f'(x)\vert $ is smallest.

Find where $f'(x) = 0$ or is closest to 0.

Show Answer

$f(x) = x^2 - 4x + 5$

$f'(x) = 2x - 4$

$f'(x) = 0$ when $x = 2$.

At a critical point, the derivative is zero, so $dy = f'(x) \cdot dx = 0 \cdot dx = 0$.

Answer: (B) $x = 2$

Near a local minimum or maximum, the function is "flat," so small changes in $x$ cause almost no change in $y$. This is one reason why optimization problems focus on critical points!

Mastery Checklist

Mental Model

The "Amplification Factor" Analogy:

Think of the derivative $f'(x)$ as an amplifier or attenuator for errors:

Power functions illustrate this clearly:


Connections

Looking back:

Looking ahead:

Real-world connections:


Previous Up Next
Differentials Skills Index Section 10: Related Rates

Last updated: 2026-01-22